SOURCE: The St. Petersburg Times
DATE: Issue #1062 (28), Tuesday, April 19, 2005
**************************************************************************
TITLE: Families
Eye Return
Of Palaces
PUBLISHER: Staff Writer
TEXT: Buildings in the center of St. Petersburg that the Bolsheviks confiscated should be given to descendants of the original owners, a round table was told last week.
Representatives of the Russian Empire Union and the organization Our Heritage and Alexander Chuyev, a State Duma lawmaker, who has drafted a bill on restitution, took part.
The round table, organized by Rosbalt, addressed the concerns of descendants of noble families for the fate of St. Petersburg's Palaces.
"If privatization takes place in Russia without any discussion on restitution, this would be illegal and immoral," Chuyev, a Rodina deputy, said at the round table on Thursday.
"The question of the privatization of cultural memorials should be approached in a way that respects the descendants of those who owned them," he said. "The nationalizations should be condemned and the descendants should be given the right to determine what happens to the properties. Apologies should be made to descendants of those people who were deprived of their property."
While conceding that the time is not right for the buildings to be restored to the families of the former owners, participants at the round table said that in the future the government should revisit the issue and that descendants would lobby for more progress to be made on restitution.
Many of the buildings that were once palaces belonging to noble families are today apartment blocks and some apartments have been privatized. Even those that are not residential and are entirely state-owned have been poorly maintained.
While other former Socialist countries have addressed the issue of returning confiscated real estate, Russia has shown little initiative on the issue and many citizens are opposed to it.
"It would be a significant step if the leadership of the country rehabilitated its relations with compatriots, many of whom live abroad," Chuyev said. His bill, which urged that architectural y significant sites be handed to the descendants of their former owners, has been filed in the State Duma, but was rejected by the Duma's property committee.
Meanwhile, representatives of the former owners admitted that the topic might be too sensitive to raise in the current circumstances.
"We don't call for restitution, but we want to attract the attention of society to this problem," said Boris Turovsky, head of the Russian Empire Union.
"The architectural sites have two kind of owners, a factual and historical. The historical successors can prove their rights in court," Turovsky said.
However, he said that if a law on restitution is passed it could lead to social unrest.
"We don't want a second revolution," he said.
Chuyev said almost every building in the center of St. Petersburg could be subject to claims from the descendants of the former owners and could theoretically be returned if it was taken away against the will of the owners, according to the Civil Code.
But, considering that the descendants have had little success to get the buildings in the past 12 years, this is a theoretical possibility only, he added.
Since 1993, when talks on restitution started in earnest, almost the only former owner of seized sites to have succeeded in getting back even part of its former real estate is the Russian Orthodox Church. At the same time several groups representing the interests of former owners, such as the Moscow-based Union of Merchants, have failed to prove their ownership rights in court, according to reports in the local media.
Princess Vera Obolenskaya, who grew up in France and has moved to St. Petersburg, said when she came back she found an estate that had belonged to her family in the Tverskaya region was in an awful condition.
"There are only ruins left, but in the past we exported cheese to Holland from there," she said.
"This is just a nightmare. There are only poor peasants left everywhere around," Obolenskaya said.
"The question of restitution was not initiated by us, but by the St. Petersburg governor, when she said that if buildings that are considered as architectural monuments are put up for sale, descendants will have the first right to buy them," Interfax quoted Dmitry Shakhovsky, honorary chairman of Our Heritage, as saying Thursday.
"I am more concerned about the legal and moral aspects of this question, but not the practical one," he said. "I am concerned about protecting the appearance of these buildings and about the future of the city."
But the restitution seems to be far from a priority for Governor Valentina Matviyenko.
"It is unlikely that there will be any developments on this matter in the near future," Natalya Kutabayeva, the governor's spokeswoman, said Friday in a telephone interview. "There hasn't been any information on it recently."
n
Matviyenko and LUKoil president Vagit Alekperov in April last year signed an agreement that the oil company will invest up to $100 million in the local fuel market development until 2007, and spend another $30 million renovating the Stieglitz Palace at 68 Angliiskaya Naberezhnaya. But last week LUKoil backed out of its plans to renovate the palace.
"It was planned to renovate part of the palace to be used for the office of the company, but it was unsuitable," LUKoil's press service said Monday.
TITLE: Envoys
Get Police
Hotline
PUBLISHER: Staff Writer
TEXT: Foreign diplomats working in St. Petersburg last week reached an agreement with city police to create a direct line of communication with local law enforcement management over improper police behavior and hate crimes that the police take no action on, representatives of foreign missions said.
"Sometimes the police behaves impolitely, not only in relation to foreign citizens, but also to representatives of diplomatic missions that are working here," Ruben Akopyan, dean of the city's diplomatic corps, said Monday in an interview. "It sometimes happens that the police do not know the rights of such people and how they should act toward them.
"We have reached an agreement that if anything of this nature occurs, we will inform the head of the police or a person responsible [for this question]," he said.
Akopyan said neither he nor any other staff of the Armenian Consulate in St. Petersburg had been ill treated by police, but indirectly suggested that unpleasant incidents have affected representatives of other diplomatic missions.
"Nothing of the kind has happened to me or people who work with me. But if incidents of this or any other kind do happen, we solve them using the law," he said.
The latest reported case when diplomats were allegedly maltreated by police officers happened at the end of January, when an unidentified man stopped an Audi car with a Polish license plate on Zvenigorodskaya Ulitsa and took the diplomat's ID card. The criminal demanded $200 for the card to be returned, local media reported.
The city police could not be reached for comment Monday.
The U.S. embassy in Moscow on Monday warned its citizens about racist attacks that could be initiated by skinheads on April 20, May 1 and May 9.
"In previous years, extremist groups, particularly 'skinhead groups,' have marked these holidays by assaulting people of color, and in particular, by targeting foreigners. These groups are very dangerous and should be avoided. When out in town, do your best to avoid anyone resembling a skinhead," the embassy wrote on its web site.
"They typically shave their heads and wear black leather clothing with Nazi swastikas. Tourist areas ... are frequently targeted by skinheads," the letter said, "The police have informed us of the potential for problems on the anniversary of Hitler's birthday [on Wednesday] and have assured us that they will take every precaution deemed appropriate to ensure public safety."
Human rights advocates have expressed their hope that the police will do their job on Wednesday, but say what they do on other days is a big question.
"I hope it will not be that dangerous for April 20 because the police is expected to act," Yury Vdovin, co-head of the St. Petersburg branch of human rights organization Citizen's Watch. "The problem is that we live between fascism and communism, and I won't be happy if either of these sides win."
"Foreigners, especially those who don't appear to be from the West, should unfortunately always beware in Russia," he said Monday in an interview.
Russia has almost as many skinheads as the rest of the world put together, the Moscow bureau for human rights says.
"There are about 50,000 skinheads in Russia. In comparison, in the rest of the world, except Russia, there are not more than 70,000," Interfax quoted Semyon Chyorny, an expert with the bureau, as saying Monday.
St. Petersburg has the most skinheads - some 10,000 to 15,000, the expert said.
The northern capital is followed by Nizhny Novgorod with up to 2,500 skinheads, Rostov-on-Don with more than 1,500 and up to 1,000 in Kaliningrad, Pskov, Yekaterinburg and Krasnodar. There are several hundred skinheads in each of Voronezh, Samara, Saratov, Krasnoyarsk, Irkutsk, Omsk, Tomsk, Vladivostok, Ryazan and Petrozavodsk, he said.
The groups are not united, operate independently and usually include up to several tens of members, the human rights advocate said.
"If in the past the groups of skinheads existed only in major cities and the towns of the southern part of Russia where the interethnic relations are tense, today we can talk about this movement spreading to all the territories, to the regional and district centers," he said.
Most of the 40 killings committed on the grounds of national hatred in 2004 in Russia were by skinheads, Chyorny said.
TITLE: Three Regions Vote to Merge in Referendum
PUBLISHER: Staff Writer
TEXT: MOSCOW - Three sparsely populated regions in Western Siberia have overwhelmingly agreed in a weekend referendum to merge to create Russia's second-largest region, according to preliminary poll results released Monday.
The proposed unification of Krasnoyarsk, Taimyr and the Evenkia Autonomous District is in line with a Kremlin drive to consolidate its grip on the country and reduce the number of regions from the current 89, political analysts said.
More than 92 percent of voters in Krasnoyarsk approved the merger in the referendum Sunday, as did about 70 percent of voters in Taimyr and 79 percent in Evenkia, Interfax reported.
Authorities of all three regions took pains to get people out to vote amid worries that turnout might fall below the required minimum of 50 percent. Krasnoyarsk Governor Alexander Khloponin, Taimyr Governor Oleg Budargin and Evenkia Governor Boris Zolotaryov traveled extensively in their regions, often going from village to village, Kommersant reported.
Izvestia said President Vladimir Putin courted voters by, among other things, signing a decree that promises Kremlin backing for 200 billion rubles in investment in the merged territory.
Voter turnout in Krasnoyarsk and Taimyr was about 53 percent, while 73 percent of voters participated in Evenkia, Interfax reported.
"The publicity drive was just excellent. People were promised a better life and new streets and hospitals," said Maxim Dianov, director of the Institute for Regional Problems, a think tank. "People are expecting a lot."
Krasnoyarsk, which is home to Norilsk Nickel and a giant RusAl aluminum smelter, is a net contributor to the state budget, while the federal government spends 2 billion rubles per year in subsidies to support Taimyr and Evenkia.
Krasnoyarsk has a population of 2.9 million, while Taimyr has 37,000 people and Evenkia has 18,000.
The three regions were part of the same region in Soviet times but were divided by the post-Soviet government to give autonomy to the native people of Taimyr and Evenkia.
The merged region would be the largest after the Sakha republic.
Sunday's referendum came after the Perm and Komi regions voted to merge in December 2003. That unification has yet to be completed.
Political analysts said the latest referendum will pave the way for a series of similar initiatives intended to cut the number of regions.
State Duma Deputy Speaker Lyubov Sliska said in comments published in Izvestia on Monday that Russia should have no more than 35 to 40 regions.
TITLE: Trepashkin Gets Another Year
PUBLISHER: The Associated Press
TEXT: MOSCOW - A Moscow regional court on Friday added another year to the prison term of former FSB officer Mikhail Trepashkin after convicting him of an additional charge of illegal arms possession, his lawyer said.
In a case that human rights activists see as politically driven, Trepashkin was convicted in 2003 and sentenced to four years in prison on charges that included disclosing state secrets.
He has denied all the charges, insisting they were fabricated by the Federal Security Service to avenge his investigation into a series of apartment bombings in 1999.
On Friday, the Dmitrov City Court, outside Moscow, found Trepashkin guilty of illegal possession and transport of weapons for a gun that law enforcement officials say they found in his car in October 2003.
Trepashkin contends the gun was planted.
Trepashkin and his lawyers say he is being prosecuted to put an end to his investigation into the suspected involvement of the FSB in the 1999 bombings.
Lipster said she will appeal.
TITLE: Starovoitova Motive 'Political'
PUBLISHER: The St. Petersburg Times
TEXT: State Duma Deputy Galina Starovoitova was assassinated for political motives, the state prosecutor says.
Deputy city prosecutor Alexander Korsunov made this conclusion about the 1998 slaying of the liberal St. Petersburg deputy in a speech posted on his web site on Friday, Interfax reported.
He did not suggest what the political motives might be. Friends and family of Starovoitova believe that the executors have been found and are on trial, but that whoever ordered the slaying has influence in political circles and prosecutors have not wanted to name them.
"Considering that Starovoitova had no other activities than her state and public ones, and that the obtaining of personal information about her and where she was can have nothing to do with the returning of any debts and the lack of any control over a commercial enterprise leaves a political motive as the only motive of the actions of the criminal group against her," Interfax quoted him saying.
Korsunov said that the assassins did not take either Starovoitova's money or her valuables.
"In the black handbag found with Starovoitova we found a mobile telephone, 855 rubles in cash, credit cards in Starovoitova's name, some foreign currency including a 1,000 Deutschmark note and about 18 $100 notes," he said.
According to Starovoitova's sister, Olga, the money had been earned during a visit to a U.S. university and was to be used to buy a television and to repair an apartment.
"The sum of the evidence shows that her valuables were not taken by her attackers and it follows that the purpose of the assault was not to acquire property," Korsunov said.
On April 4, Korsunov asked for the suspects Yury Kolchin and Vitaly Akinshinas to be jailed for at least 10 years to prison, that Yury Ionov and Igor Krasnov, be sent to a hard-labor colony for 15 years, that Igor Lelyavin be jailed for 12 years and that Alexander Voronin, in the light of his cooperation with investigators be jailed for only 41/2 years.
Voronin last week pleaded guilty to monitoring Starovoitova's telephone calls, but other suspects have not admitted their guilt.
Ruslan Linkov, Starovoitova's assistant who was severly injured during the assassination said Lelyavin threatened Voronin in the courtroom.
"Voronin might soon leave the jail, so I wish him long years ... no, long days of life and health," Lelyavin said according to the witness.
"When asked if it was a threat he said, 'Yes,'" Linkov said.
The defense had argued that the suspects were Christian and would not take a human life. he said.
But a relative of one suspect had pointed at Linkov during a break in the trial and said told a child to take revenge when he grew up.
"'Look, these are the people who put your father in jail, so when you grow up you should get busy with them,' the woman said. That shows very well their attitude to Christianity," Linkov said.
The trial has been running since the start of last year and is in its final stages. The next hearing is due on May 23.
Three suspects are still at large and another, Pavel Stekhnovsky, was extradited from Belgium in December.
TITLE: City Has 'Plenty of Eroticism'
PUBLISHER: Staff Writer
TEXT: Sex is the main factor for human development, says German erotic-art collector Hans-Jurgen Dopp, who is in St. Petersburg to give a lecture on erotic art on Wednesday.
Dopp, 65, said he began his collection 40 years ago. Today it consists of about 5,000 erotic drawings, lithographs, and water colors by international artists, including Pablo Picasso, Salvador Dali and Hans Bellmar.
"I don't find my hobby unusual," he said Monday in an interview. "On the contrary, I am surprised that not all men collect such items because everyone is interested in the topic."
Asked how erotic art differs from pornography, he said pornography is essentially a moral term while what interests him in erotic art is the portrayal of sexuality as an expression of freedom.
"There's plenty of eroticism in the palaces of St. Petersburg," he said. "For instance, at Pavlovsk many artworks show naked women's breasts."
Most artists have created erotic works at some time in their life, but erotic art is still rather rare because many of them have been destroyed at times when they were forbidden, he said.
Cultural traditions and the Christian church, which emphasized the development of the spirit rather than the flesh, were mainly responsible for the curbing of erotic art, he said.
Erotic art varies in line with the country it comes from.
German erotic art often presents a dark variant of sexuality, and can even be anti-erotic because of its connection with violence. While French erotic artists have much lighter view, he said.
Dopp said that there are thousands of forms of sexuality, which all have the right to exist, except those that involve sexual violence and children.
Dopp's lecture will be given at St. Petersburg's Soitology Institute, which publishes erotic literature and aims to educate people about sex. He will talk about the history of erotic art starting from the Renaissance, and why this art was often forbidden.
He will show about150 slides from his art collection at the lecture.
Neonilla Samukhina, director of the Soitology Institute, said Dopp's will be the first public lecture at the institute, and is open to anyone older than 18.
Information about the lecture can be obtained at tel. 315-6491 or 571-7521.
TITLE: Nashi to Fight Liberals, Bureaucrats
PUBLISHER: Staff Writer
TEXT: MOSCOW - New youth movement Nashi, or Us, pledged to defend the policies of President Vladimir Putin against liberals, corrupt bureaucrats and fascists as it held its founding conference Friday.
Nashi appears to be a Kremlin effort to help safeguard itself against a popular uprising.
Nashi began to take shape late last year, and 30 regional branches sent 680 delegates to Friday's conference in the main building of the Russian Academy of Sciences. The delegates, mostly well-dressed college students aged 17 to 22, were greeted by Nashi flags, a white X-shaped cross on a red background, and posters of the first man in space, Yury Gagarin. Some posters read: "Yury Gagarin. That's Where Nashi Is From!"
Delegates elected Nashi founder Vasily Yakemenko as their leader, and he said he would step down as leader of Moving Together, another pro-Putin youth movement, to accept the post.
Reading from Nashi's manifesto, Yakemenko said Nashi would help Putin overcome resistance from domestic enemies such as corrupt bureaucrats and "an unnatural union of liberals, fascists, pro-Western politicians and ultranationalists," Yakemenko said.
He later told reporters that Nashi would start a campaign against Putin's enemies that would include the passing out of pamphlets. He identified Putin's enemies as liberal politicians Irina Khakamada, Vladimir Ryzhkov and Garry Kasparov, among others.
Reading from the manifesto, he said Nashi also would fight foreign foes such as "international foundations and international terrorists" and seek to counter U.S. influence. He said the United States and terrorists want to weaken Russia to gain control over it.
He said Nashi would support Putin to make Russia the world's leader and to dismantle "oligarchic capitalism."
Nashi intends to become a main political force in the 2008 presidential election, Yakemenko told reporters. It now has 3,500 members, he said.
In a sign of Kremlin support, Science and Education Minister Andrei Fursenko gave a speech in which he urged delegates to study, stay healthy and strive to help Russia create an economy based on intellect rather than oil.
He acknowledged that he had hastily drafted the speech en route to the conference and then said: "There's a catastrophic lack of ambition in the country. Let's not be afraid of challenges. Let's take them on."
Fursenko warned delegates not to demand higher stipends or employment guarantees. About 4,000 students rallied at the White House earlier in the week. Stanislav Belkovsky, a political analyst, said the well-dressed delegates at Friday's conference were a front. "It was created to unite tough youth - such as soccer fans - who are fit for street fighting and who could face off against other youth gatherings in the street," he said.
Belkovsky and political analyst Andrei Piontkovsky said the Kremlin fears an uprising such as Ukraine's Orange Revolution last year. "This [Nashi] is an organization of young fighters, a preventive measure against a possible Orange Revolution in Russia," Piontkovsky said.
He said a revolution was unlikely to happen but the authorities were scared and acting "hysterically."
Piontkovsky said the emergence of Nashi was an indication that Moving Together has failed to galvanize young people's support for Putin.
Yakemenko said Friday that Nashi was being financed by the privately owned Moscow Management Institute but was hoping to get money from big businesses and the government.
Delegates on Friday elected five "commissars" - including Yakemenko - to serve on Nashi's governing body, the federal council, and the commissars faced mocking questions at a news conference. "Are your parents aware that you are here?" one reporter said, prompting loud laughter.
"Of course my parents know," Mikhail Kulikov said, and his fellow commissars replied affirmatively.
One delegate, Anastasia Raikova, an 18-year-old student at St. Petersburg's State University of Information Technologies, Mechanics and Optics, said she learned about Nashi from a friend in November and later attended a meeting with Yakemenko. "The more you listen to him, the more you understand that he is saying smart things," she said. "This organization supports Putin's policies. It's appealing."
During the conference, a National Bolshevik Party activist jumped onto the stage and pushed bottles of water off the speakers' table. Police were holding her pending charges, the party said.
TITLE: State Duma Gives Its
Vote to Large Parties
PUBLISHER: Staff Writer
TEXT: MOSCOW - The State Duma on Friday gave its approval in the crucial second reading to legislation that would transform the lower house by ending the election of independent deputies and making it even more difficult for smaller parties to claim seats. The vote was 335 to 96.
The proposal to eliminate individual Duma races and offer voters a choice only of parties was originally pushed by Central Elections Commission chairman Alexander Veshnyakov, who said it would help Russia develop "a real party system."
It won President Vladimir Putin's support in the aftermath of the Beslan attack in September and became part of his broad plan, along with the scrapping of gubernatorial elections, for changing the political system.
The plan's opponents have said it would further increase the Kremlin's control over the Duma and ensure that it continued to operate as a rubber stamp.
"The Kremlin is just slashing the number of actors with which it would have to negotiate," said Alexei Makarkin, an analyst at the Center for Political Technologies. "It is one thing to strike a deal with two or three party leaders and another to reach accord with, say, 225 single-mandate lawmakers."
Under the current system, half of the Duma's 450 members are elected by party list and half are elected in single-mandate races.
After the Duma approved the bill in a first reading in late December, about 800 amendments were submitted. Some were submitted Thursday by Putin.
These amendments, which were approved Friday, would raise the bar for political parties to get into the Duma to 7 percent from 5 percent and would prevent small parties from forming coalitions to meet that threshold.
This would effectively lock out the smaller liberal opposition parties, since they would be prevented from joining forces ahead of the 2007 Duma elections.
"Even the small liberal factions in the Duma had easy access to the national media and, outspokenly critical, were like an irritating mosquito for the Kremlin," said Yury Korgunyuk, a political analyst at Indem. "Now the Kremlin is setting up a mosquito net against them."
The Duma slapped down a main element of Veshnyakov's original plan, which would have punished parties for stacking their party lists with governors, business leaders and celebrities. Under Veshnyakov's plan, if someone on one party's list refused to take a Duma seat, that seat would go to another party.
The Communist and nationalist Rodina factions supported this initiative. Deputy Speaker Valentin Kuptsov, a Communist, said it was intended to prevent a repeat of the situation in 2003, when United Russia had 37 regional leaders on its party lists and not one accepted a Duma seat. Veshnyakov, who said such practices deceived the voters, refused to discuss other amendments after this one was defeated 234 to 137.
The Duma refused to introduce a quota of 30 percent for women on party lists, a motion put forward by Yekaterina Lakhova, head of the Women and Family Affairs Committee. Women hold slightly more than 10 percent of Duma seats.
The Duma made it easier to bar a party from participating in an election by reducing the percentage of citizens' signatures that could be found invalid to 5 percent from 25 percent. Barring opposition parties and candidates on the premise of forged signatures has been common practice over the past decade.
Deputies supported by 307 votes an amendment put forward by United Russia that would strip the ombudsman of the right to invite international observers to monitor parliamentary elections.
The legislation would make it difficult for new political forces to emerge, despite a strong public demand for new faces, Makarkin said. "Without new people and ideas, fatigue will quickly overwhelm the public, making it less susceptible to the Kremlin's calls," he said. "Also, the authorities will be representing a smaller range of interest groups."
The new legislation, including the ban on coalitions, would apply to regional as well as national parliamentary elections.
Before becoming law, the legislation must be passed by the Duma in a third reading, approved by the Federation Council and signed by Putin.
TITLE: IN BRIEF
TEXT: No Word on 'Spy'
MOSCOW (Reuters) - A Russian diplomat was forced to leave Germany in December after German counter-intelligence and the CIA caught him buying military secrets, a German news magazine reported.
No comment was available from the German government or the Russian embassy Monday on the Der Spiegel report.
The magazine said Alexander Kuzmin, Russian consul in Hamburg, was caught at a secret meeting in a restaurant last November with a member of the German armed forces who handed him documents about communications and weapons systems.
The report said Kuzmin was summoned back to Moscow on Dec. 5 .
2 Jailed Over Bombs
n MOSCOW (AP) - A court on Friday sentenced a former Sibir airline employee and a ticket scalper to 18 months in a penal colony for their role in the bombings of two passenger jets last summer that killed all 90 people aboard the planes. Armen Arutyunyan and Nikolai Korenkov were sentenced for aiding and abetting terrorism and for commercial bribery in the Aug. 24 bombings of a Volga-Avia-express Tu-134 and a Sibir Airlines Tu-154.
Interfax reported that the court had taken mitigating personal circumstances into consideration when deciding the sentence. Arutyunyan has a child and pleaded guilty, while Korenkov has elderly parents.
EU, Russia Eye Deal
n CANACH, Luxembourg (AP) - European Union and Russian officials said Friday that they were still hopeful of clinching a deal on illegal immigration as part of a new EU-Russia cooperation pact meant to be signed on May 10.
The two sides sought to narrow differences at a meeting Friday, and Justice Minister Luc Frieden of Luxembourg said the EU and Russia were "very much on the same wavelength" on how to tackle illegal asylum seekers.
Balts and Annexation
n RIGA, Latvia (AP) - Leaders of Latvia, Lithuania and Estonia on Friday welcomed a proposed U.S. congressional resolution calling on Russia to admit the Soviet Union's annexation of Latvia, Lithuania and Estonia during World War II was illegal.