Results of Roundtable Show Opposition Still in Disarray

By Alexander Bratersky

The St. Petersburg Times

Published: September 12, 2012 (Issue # 1726)

MOSCOW — An opposition roundtable intended to unite opponents of President Vladimir Putin went largely ignored by the younger leaders of the protest movement, evidence that the protest camp is still in disarray, insiders and opponents said.

Friday’s roundtable, presided over by former Prime Minister Mikhail Kasyanov and Vladimir Ryzhkov, the leaders of the newly merged RPR-PARNAS liberal party, was one of the many attempts to call for unity in the opposition movement.

“We are sure that only peaceful methods can be used to change the regime,” Kasyanov said at the roundtable at Moscow’s Ararat Hotel on Friday.

But Kasyanov’s calls for unity, supported by some political dissidents, including Lyudmila Alexeyeva, chairman of the Moscow Helsinki human rights group, were ignored by more popular leaders of the protest movement, including Alexei Navalny, leftist politician Sergei Udaltsov and liberal Ilya Yashin.

All of them, including seasoned liberal politician Boris Nemtsov, skipped the meeting, despite being invited by the organizers.

“Many of those who didn’t come did it for ideological reasons,” Yabloko party co-chairman Sergei Ivanenko said.

“Younger leaders don’t want to unite, since they see many of the elder politicians as ‘old guys’ from the ‘90s,” a senior political strategist who helped organize the roundtable said.

She spoke on condition of anonymity because she was not authorized to speak with the press.

The absence of young leaders, including Navalny, who is seen by many as a rising star of the protest movement, was clear evidence of a divide in the opposition as it looks for a way to harness the protest sentiment in the country.

“The main way to force authorities to take part in a roundtable should be large-scale peaceful protests based on democratic values,” the roundtable’s mission statement said.

But opposition leaders who did attend the roundtable acknowledged that their powers to reach a broad Russian audience are limited because their slogans do not appeal to a mass audience of Russians who would rather support forces on the left.

“The problem with democratic forces can be described as a problem with the second word: ‘forces,’” liberal Yabloko party deputy Sergei Ivanenko said.

“Nothing changes from our talks, things change only when people get on the street,” leftwing Just Russia deputy Gennady Gudkov said during the roundtable.

The opposition’s inability to unite around a political program is noticed by political opponents as well.

“Those December protests could have been turned into a real asset, but they were not,” a United Russia State Duma deputy told The St. Petersburg Times last week.

The deputy, who spoke on condition of anonymity, said Putin might take advantage of the situation in the opposition camp by dissolving the United Russia-dominated Duma and calling for early elections.